JHORJournal of Hematology and Oncology Research2372-6601Open Access PubUnited Statesjhor-13-34610.14302/issn.2372-6601.jhor-13-346review-articleTargeting Cell Metabolism in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukaemia (CLL); Aviable Therapeutic Approach?targeting metabolism in cllChloeE. Clapham1*AndrewR. Pettitt12JosephR. Slupsky1Department of Molecular and Clinical Cancer Medicine, Institute of Translational Medicine, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, UK Department of Haematology, Royal Liverpool University Hospital, Liverpool, UKCorresponding AuthorKrzysztofRoszkowski1Department of Radiotherapy, F. Lukaszczyk Oncology Center, Poland.
Chloe E. Clapham
Haematology, Department of Molecular and Clinical Cancer Medicine, University of Liverpool, 2nd Floor Duncan Building, Daulby Street, Liverpool L69 3GA, United Kingdom0151 706 41500151 706 4311chloe.clapham@liverpool.ac.uk
The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.
Targeting cell metabolism is a therapeutic approach which has been used for the treatment of cancers with high levels of proliferation. Inhibition of metabolic processes in cancer cells has shown synergy with current therapeutic options to reduce refractory disease and relapse. In contrast, chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) is a disease where expansion of the malignant clone results from a combination of enhanced cell survival coupled with low level proliferation. The purpose of this article is to highlight how further research is needed to determine whether targeting cell metabolism may be a viable therapeutic strategy in this disease. We discuss how lymphocyte doubling time (LDT) remains a robust prognostic indicator used in the current clinical management of CLL, and how recognition of CLL as a proliferative disease has led to a greater understanding of the importance of energy-generating processes in its pathobiology. We summarize what is currently known about normal B cell metabolism and consider whether there is evidence of the Warburg effect in CLL cells. Finally, we speculate on how CLL cells may exploit protective mechanisms such as autophagy during times of metabolic stress and how they might influence or be influenced by metabolic characteristics of the microenvironment.
Chronic lymphocytic leukaemia (CLL) is a common haemic malignancy predominantly of aging adults affecting males more frequently than females.1 This disease is characterized by the accumulation of CD5+ CD20+ CD23+ B cell lymphocytes in the blood, lymph nodes, liver, spleen and bone marrow.2 CLL has a highly variable clinical course in which aggressive disease is characterised by a high tumour burden or, in cases with a low tumour burden, a progressive increase in blood lymphocytes over a period of months. In contrast, in indolent disease the blood lymphocyte count may remain stable over a period of years.3 The lymphocyte doubling time (LDT) was first described in the mid-eighties for its importance in determining CLL prognosis. Specifically, it was shown that patients with a LDT of less than 12 months had a significantly shorter survival time.4 A number of biological markers have subsequently been identified that can separate patients into prognostic groups. These include IGHV mutational status, expression of CD38 and Zeta-chain-associated protein kinase 70 (ZAP-70) and genetic anomalies such as TP53 mutation/deletion.567 Although these factors give some insight into the pathogenesis of CLL and likely prognosis, their ability to reliably predict disease progression in individual patients is limited. Therefore, the decision to commence treatment is still based upon a “wait and watch” strategy whereby therapeutic intervention is applied only once the tumour burden is sufficiently high to cause symptoms or complications, or if the LDT is less than 6 months.3 Thus, LDT remains an important variable in CLL, both as a prognostic factor and also as a guide to treatment initiation.3
In the past it was thought that this characteristic increase in the LDT was due to failed apoptosis.8 Early studies on whole blood samples revealed that the majority of CLL cells are arrested in G0 of the cell cycle, suggesting that lymphocytosis in this disease did not reflect proliferation of the circulating malignant clone.89 Moreover, it was found that CLL cells had high expression levels of anti-apoptotic proteins such as Mcl-1 and Bcl-2 and low expression of pro-apoptotic proteins such as Bax.10111213 In particular, high levels of Mcl-1 expression were correlated with resistance to chemotherapeutic agents such as chlorambucil and fludarabine.13 Genetic lesions have also been shown to have an anti-apoptotic effect. For example, deletion of p53 (del17p13) leads to the loss of p53-mediated cell death in CLL.14 This is important because agents such as fludarabine exploit the p53 pathway as a mechanism of inducing death of CLL cells, providing one explanation for the evolution of drug resistant clones and the process of relapse.1415
It has since been recognised that proliferation plays a major role in CLL pathogenesis.16 A pivotal study by Messmer, et al. 16 used deuterium to label DNA of newly-formed CLL cells and showed that progressive disease was associated with malignant-cell daily birth rates greater than 0.35% of the entire clone. Other studies comparing CLL patients with healthy control subjects have shown that, although CLL cell turnover is lower than that of normal B cells, the rate at which deuterium-labelled CLL cells disappear from circulation is considerably slower.217 Thus, malignant-cell accumulation in CLL is likely dictated by a combination of cell proliferation and resistance to apoptosis, with the longer life span of CLL cells allowing them to relocate into environments that support their survival and further promote proliferation.
Most studies investigating the pathogenesis of CLL continue to focus on mechanisms that promote cell survival and resistance to apoptosis. Very few studies have investigated cell metabolism as a therapeutic target in CLL.1819202122 Recognition of proliferation as a major contributor to the progression of this disease calls for a re-examination of cell metabolism in CLL cells. This is because a key checkpoint in the decision of cells to progress to S phase and undergo proliferation is metabolic status (Figure 1). This makes sense because cells require sufficient macromolecular building blocks and energy in order to successfully complete the process of dividing into daughter cells.23 In a high energy state where the ratio of ATP to AMP is high, a sensor protein known as AMP-kinase (AMPK) remains in an inactive state. This allows employment of the anabolic processes that allow cell growth and proliferation, as well as facilitating spindle orientation during mitosis.24 However, in a low energy state where the level of AMP rises as ATP is depleted, AMPK becomes phosphorylated and active, and works to control the resources available to the cell.2526 Activated AMPK does this by inducing catabolic processes such as glycolysis and autophagy, and also blocking cell-cycle progression regulating the function of cyclins and cyclin dependant kinases (CDKs).2527 In normal cells, metabolic control of proliferation is influenced by growth factors that stimulate nutrient intake, whereas in malignant cells the role of growth factors can be over-ridden by oncogenic mutations in genes controlling cellular growth.
The role of activated AMPK in regulating the cell cycle.
Clearly, there have been many advances in our understanding of CLL since the first studies of CLL cell metabolism in the late 1950s. For example, it was recognised that somatic hypermutation of IGHV genes coding for the B cell receptor (BCR) on CLL cells could be used to differentiate between patients who were likely to have progressive disease; CLL patients whose malignant cells bear unmutated IGHV genes (UM-CLL) are more likely to have progressive disease than those having mutated IGHV genes (M-CLL).528 Analysis of gene expression in UM- and M-CLL cells lead to the discovery that expression of ZAP-70 in CLL cells was connected with poor disease prognosis.2930 These observations have led to the development of a hypothesis suggesting that BCR signalling is a major contributor to CLL pathogenesis, particularly with respect to aggressive disease.31 Other factors associated with progressive disease include CD38 expression and genetic abnormalities leading to inactivation of ATM and p53.567 Furthermore, mutation in genes such as SF3B1, NOTCH1 and XPO1 have also been correlated with progressive disease.14323334353637 Finally, it is recognised that the pseudofollicles that form in patients with CLL provide an environment that is particularly adept at promoting malignant cell survival and proliferation.1138 These factors, either alone or in combination, are likely to determine the precise pattern of behaviour of individual CLL clones.
This article will consider what is known about CLL cell metabolism and examine whether this knowledge needs to be updated in light of new understanding of CLL pathobiology. The therapeutic potential of targeting metabolism in CLL will then be assessed in the light of this improved understanding.
Normal B-Cell Versus CLL-Cell Metabolism
In order to contextualise the metabolic characteristics of CLL cells, an understanding of bioenergetics in normal B cells is needed. Some insight into this process is provided in a recent study by Garcia-Manteiga, et al. 39 who have examined the metabolic profile of B cells as they undergo a transition from resting naive lymphocytes into immunoglobulin-secreting plasma cells. Figure 2 illustrates these changes. Naïve/resting B cells are shown to rely primarily on oxidative phosphorylation for energy production. However, following exposure to antigen these cells begin to utilize aerobic glycolysis as a primary energy source as they become activated and then transit through the germinal centre. While the use of aerobic glycolysis as a metabolic adaptation has reduced efficiency for ATP generation, it confers numerous benefits including a rapid production of the metabolic intermediates and ATP that are required by activated splenic B cells to meet the demands of cell replication.40 A similar process has been described for T cells undergoing activation via the T cell receptor (TCR) and CD28, suggesting a common mechanism of lymphocyte response to antigen receptor stimulation. Importantly, following depletion of glucose stores, T cells further adapt their metabolism by promoting entry of glutamine into the Tricarboxylic acid cycle (TCA cycle) in a process known as glutaminolysis.41 This is likely also to occur in B cells within the splenic environment since increased glutaminolysis prevails as the source of energy production in antibody-producing plasma cells (Figure 2).39 Activated B cells can also differentiate to memory B cells. These cells assume a resting phenotype similar to that associated with naïve B cells, and they regain dependence on oxidative phosphorylation as the primary means of energy generation.
Whether or not CLL cells undergo the same metabolic changes experienced by differentiating normal B cells has not been investigated. Examination of the surface membrane phenotype of CLL cells has shown them to express markers of activation and differentiation, suggesting they resemble antigen-experienced B cells.42 The work by Garcia-Manteiga, et al. 39 on B-cell bioenergetics suggests that circulating CLL cells may rely on oxidative phosphorylation as their primary means of energy generation owing to their resting state. This notion is supported by Moran, et al. 43 who showed that high levels of oxidative stress experienced by CLL cells in the circulation is the result of aerobic mitochondrial respiration. However, a recent study of metabolites in serum samples from CLL patients shows increased levels of pyruvate and glutamate compared to serum samples from normal participants.19 Further analysis comparing the metabolic profile of serum samples between UM-CLL and M-CLL patients revealed that increased lactate, fumarate and uridine levels were associated with UM-CLL patients indicating that UM-CLL cells have a greater reliance on glycolysis. While this study did not directly examine CLL cell metabolism, the implications are that the changes in metabolic profile observed between CLL cells and normal cells are caused by metabolic reprogramming of CLL cells.19
Metabolic adaptations following the activation of normal B cells.
The Warburg Effect: Is Metabolic Deregulation Occurring in CLL Cells?
Reprogramming of key metabolic mediators is characteristic of the Warburg effect, a phenomenon whereby malignant cells upregulate glycolytic activity in the presence of oxygen and rapidly consume glucose.44 That UM-CLL cells may have greater reliance on glycolysis for energy production19 agrees with the model of aerobic glycolysis induction following BCR stimulation in normal B cells.39 This is supported by an existing paradigm whereby UM-CLL cells experience constitutive in-vivo signalling through the BCR4546, and from studies demonstrating that UM-CLL cells derive from pre-germinal centre CD5+ B cells whereas M-CLL cells derive from post-germinal centre CD5+, CD27+ B cells.47 BCR stimulated induction of glycolysis is demonstrated to involve protein kinase Cβ (PKCβ)48, and CLL cells may be particularly sensitive because they overexpress PKCβII.49 That metabolic reprogramming is a feature of CLL cells comes from a study of sucrose isomaltase function in relation to mutation. Sucrose isomaltase is the fifth most mutated gene in CLL, and mutations resulting in loss of enzyme function are associated with increased expression of genes associated with glucose metabolism.50 Furthermore, Tili, et al. 51 have correlated metabolic reprogramming with poor prognosis and have demonstrated that reduced expression of the microRNA (miR) miR-125b in CLL cells leads to increased expression of enzymes involved in glucose metabolism, potentially explaining observed increased levels of glycolytic intermediates in plasma and urine of CLL patients with progressive disease. In addition to this, microRNA’s known to be deregulated in CLL have been shown to play an important role modulating metabolic pathways in other cell types.52535455 For instance, two of the most important microRNA’s in relation to CLL pathogenesis; miR-15a, miR-16 have been implicated in the regulation of ATP generating processes as has another microRNA; miR-195.52 Other microRNA’s associated with mitochondrial function such as miR-23a/b, miR-126, and miR-155 have also been shown to mediate glucose metabolism.52535657 However, early studies examining glucose uptake by CLL cells show that they consume less glucose than do normal B lymphocytes.8 Studies using fluorodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (FDG-PET) to visualise CLL cells in vivo have met with poor results; sensitivity of detection was 53% and the extent of disease was often underestimated.58 This may be because CLL is composed of malignant cell fractions with different proliferative activities whereby recently divided cells and older/quiescent cells may have different glucose requirements. This notion is supported by a report indicating that CLL patients have two populations of circulating malignant cells with different degrees of mitochondrial polarisation and dependencies on glucose.59 Where FDG-PET has been effectively used in CLL management is with respect to the detection of Richter’s transformation.60 In this situation CLL cells change into faster growing diffuse large B cell lymphoma (DLBCL) or Hodgkin’s lymphoma cells and likely gain independence from the microenvironmental cues that normally regulate their proliferation. The increased need of glucose by these cells may be due to activation of the Jak/STAT and PI3K/Akt/mTOR signalling pathways as has been suggested by a study comparing metabolic profiles between activated T cell lymphocytes and lymphoma cells.61
While the level of glucose uptake experienced by CLL cells appears to be at odds with the high glucose consumption that is characteristic of the Warburg effect, the glycolytic pathway is nevertheless important to CLL cell pathophysiology. This is because treatment of CLL cells with the hexokinase inhibitor lonidamine has been shown to result in decreased cell viability in vitro and in reductions in lymphocyte count as well as in the size of the lymph nodes and spleen when it is used in vivo.18 Furthermore, a more recent study by Tidmarsh, et al. 62 has shown that inhibition of the glycolytic pathway in CLL cells using 2-deoxyglucose (2DG) results in a reduction of ATP levels followed by a loss of cell viability. The lower level of glucose uptake in CLL cells may reflect the use of an alternative source of glucose. A possible candidate of this alternative source is glycogen which has been shown to accumulate in CLL cells63, negating the need for glucose uptake. However, this simple explanation is complicated by observations that glycogen phosphorylase activity in PHA-activated CLL cells is lower than that in normal lymphocytes64, indicating that CLL cells may have reduced capability of converting glycogen to glucose. Alternatively hypoxia inducible factor 1α (HIF-1α) may be responsible for increased glycogen storage as it is reported to do in other cancerous and non-cancerous cells.65 Expression of HIF-1α is raised in circulating CLL cells due to down regulation of von Hippel-Lindau (pVHL) protein which catalyses HIF-1a degradation.66 Importantly, studies of glucose uptake/usage by CLL cells have mainly been performed on cultured cells. Cultured CLL cells, like those in circulation are mainly in G0, and their requirement for glucose may be very low. These cells may rely on oxidative phosphorylation as we have already discussed, explaining why drugs such as lonidamine and 2DG have their cytotoxic effects. Finally, CLL cells may utilize fatty acid oxidation as a source of glucose as has been suggested in a recent paper by Spaner, et al. 22. Here they demonstrate that PPARα, a mediator of fatty acid oxidation, is upregulated in circulating CLL cells, and that CLL cells show in vitro and in vivo sensitivity to a specific inhibitor of PPARα, MK886.
Coping in Times of Metabolic Stress: Autophagy and Metabolic Adaptations to Quiescence in CLL Cells
CLL cells survive in the circulation for a considerably longer time than do normal B cells.2 In this regard the longer a CLL cell clone can survive in circulation, the better chance it will have of re-entering tissues where it will receive signals for proliferation and enhanced survival. The prolonged lifespan of CLL cells in circulation likely results from a combination of apoptotic resistance mechanisms and metabolic adaptations that help to maintain viability.65 One such metabolic adaptation may result from the increased expression of HIF-1α which may maintain CLL cells in an arrested state and hold them from progressing to cellular senescence by inhibiting mammalian target of rapamycin (mTOR) (Figure 3).676869 This HIF-1a-induced adoption of a quiescent phenotype may explain why early studies showed that CLL cells consume less glucose than do normal B lymphocytes8, and why CLL cells are not easily imaged by FDG-PET.58 Moreover, adoption of a quiescent phenotype may be related to progressive disease in CLL because malignant cell susceptibility to apoptosis, low level RNA content and high expression of p27kip1 all correlate to patients with late stage disease.677071 This relationship is supported by further observations showing that UM-CLL and ZAP-70 expression in CLL cells also correlate with ability to adopt a quiescent phenotype.72
Regulation of cell metabolism via mTORC1 and mTORC2 following BCR and CD40 stimulation.
Another consequence of mTOR inhibition is the induction of autophagy, a self-digestive process initiated in cells experiencing metabolic stress. During autophagy catabolism of internal organelles is activated to generate the ATP that is necessary to maintain essential housekeeping functions and cell survival.6973 CLL cells are reported to experience autophagy; one early study has suggested that as much as one third of the overall protein degradation that takes place in these cells is due to this process74, while more recent studies have suggested that IL-24 induces its pro-survival effect by inducing autophagy in CLL cells.75 A study by Mahoney, et al. 76 has also shown CLL cells to express the ATG family of proteins critical for autophagy in addition to demonstrating autophagy induction by known agents. Furthermore, our own unpublished observations indicate that a major regulator of mTOR, AMPK, is constitutively phosphorylated on the serine residues associated with enzyme activation, and that phospho-AMPK levels seem to be increased in UM-CLL compared to M-CLL cells. This observation agrees with a published result showing that an activator of AMPK, sirtuin 1 (SIRT1), is upregulated in CLL cells.77 That autophagy in CLL cells has a cytoprotective effect is recently demonstrated in a study showing that re-expression of the miRNA gene miR-130a inhibits autophagy in CLL cells and sensitizes them to apoptosis.78 Moreover, a further study by Maccallum, et al. 79 has shown similar re-sensitization to apoptosis when autophagy in CLL cells is disrupted by the SIRT1 inhibitor Tenovin-6.
Excessive stimulation of autophagy can also result in apoptosis through a process called autophagic cell death (ACD).80 In this process organelle digestion continues beyond the point that can be restored when metabolic stress is removed. ACD is observed in CLL cells that have been treated with the AMP analogue acadesine (AICAR), due to the ability of this compound to activate AMPK and inhibit mTOR function.81 A study by Santidrian, et al. 82 has shown this effect can occur independently of AMPK and p53 in CLL cells via the Bcl-2 family proteins; BIM, NOXA and PUMA. Further to this, the death inducing effects of the glucocorticoid dexamethasone has been reported to arise due to the stimulation of autophagy in CLL cells.8083 Notably, UM-CLL cells have been found to be significantly more sensitive to dexamethasone-induced killing in keeping with the observations that these cells have greater levels of AMPK activation and may be more readily pushed over the edge to ACD.84 A further study by Mahoney, et al. 76 describes how other select chemotherapeutic agents such as fludarabine, the PI3K δ-isoform inhibitor CAL-101, thapsigargin and flavopiridol all stimulate the induction of autophagy prior to inducing apoptotic cell death. However, the cytotoxic effect of thapsigargin and flavopiridol can be enhanced following disruption of ER stress-induced autophagy, suggesting that autophagy induced through this mechanism is protective against cell death and promotes drug resistance. This mechanism of autophagy has been associated with dasatinib resistance in CLL patients.85
Although autophagy has been studied extensively from the perspective of protection from metabolic stress in circulating cells, it has also been shown to have a role within the microenvironment. Recycling of nutrients may occur not only within the cancerous cells themselves but also in the adjacent stroma as a means of providing nutrients to promote invasion and metastasis.8687 A possible mechanism of autophagy induction and metabolic reprogramming in adjacent stromal cells is through the generation of oxidative stress76 as has been observed in the tumour microenvironment of breast cancer.88 This study showed that the production of reactive oxygen species (ROS) by breast cancer cells causes the bordering fibroblasts to switch to glycolysis and generate fuel for the breast cancer cells in the form of pyruvate, which then feeds into oxidative phosphorylation. This synergistic relationship is called the reverse Warburg effect because of the induction of the abnormal glycolytic phenotype in the supporting fibroblasts as opposed to the malignant breast cancer cells. This symbiosis is suggested to occur via shuttling of metabolic intermediates such as lactate and pyruvate through monocarboxylate transporters (MCT) -1 and -4 on cancerous cells and the cells of the microenvironment.8990
Microenvironmental Influences on CLL Cell Bioenergetics
The relationship between the microenvironment and CLL cells is important, particularly in the context of apoptotic resistance and induction of cell proliferation. The interaction of quiescent CLL cells with the microenvironment has been modelled using supportive cells such as bone marrow stromal cells, endothelial cells and parental fibroblasts as well as fibroblasts which express CD40 ligand (CD40L) to simulate the influence of T helper cells on CLL cell proliferation. Soluble factors such as IL-21 and IL-4 may also be added to the system to replicate cytokines secreted by T cells.91 Thus, these co-culture systems are thought to mirror the interactions which occur in vivo to induce cell activation, division and enhanced survival in CLL.92 What is missing is an assessment of the impact these interactions have on the metabolism of these cells. Existing studies of these interactions may be useful in directing future research. For example, a study by Willimott and Wagner 93 describes changes in the profile of microRNA’s (miR’s) expressed in CLL cells following co-culture with parental and CD40L-expressing fibroblasts. This study identified multiple miR’s that were deregulated in CLL cells cultured on fibroblasts and a cursory examination of miR’s that potentially regulate metabolic pathways can be observed. In particular, incubation of CLL cells with parental fibroblasts induces changes in the expression of miR-125b (whose effects we discuss in a previous section of this review) along with let-7c which is known to regulate glucose metabolism as part of the lin28/let-7 pathway.94 Furthermore, incubation with CD40L-expressing fibroblasts induces increased expression of miR-155, which can function in regulating glycolytic activity.95 The effect of CD40L on CLL cells may be akin to that observed on similarly stimulated endothelial cells where activation of mTOR (Figure 3) and an increase in cell size has been demonstrated.96 Our own unpublished experiments of CLL cells co-cultured with CD40L-expressing fibroblasts show increased cell size providing support for this direction of endeavour. Moreover, a phase 2 clinical trial testing the mTOR inhibitor everolimus shows that this compound can stimulate mobilization of CLL cells from nodal tissues into the circulation, suggesting that the mTOR pathway may be important for maintaining CLL cells within the microenvironment.97 With respect to cytokines, IL-4 has been shown to have a role in the regulation of glucose levels in normal B cells98, but this remains unexamined in CLL cells. Finally, interaction with adhesion molecules such as E-Cadherin could possibly regulate metabolic processes through the induction of HIF-1α expression as has been demonstrated for breast cancer cells.99
CLL cells may also influence their microenvironment and reprogram it to provide protection from oxidative stress and clearance by the immune system. A recent study by Lutzny, et al. 100 showed that CLL cell contact with stromal cells induced expression of PKCβII in these cells which resulted in activation of the NFκB pathway and secretion of growth factors that, in turn, enhanced the survival of the CLL cells. Zhang, et al. 101 has also demonstrated how CLL cell survival is enhanced by modifications to the supportive cells. In this study bone marrow stromal cells are shown to supply the metabolic intermediate cysteine to CLL cells. This is important for CLL cell survival because this amino acid is required for the production of glutathione (GSH), a redox mediator which prevents the accumulation of ROS.
Conclusions
The purpose of this manuscript is to highlight the need for further research to assess whether targeting cell metabolism may be a viable strategy for the treatment of CLL, a disease with a low level of proliferative activity. While some studies have successfully targeted metabolism in CLL the metabolic pathways used by these cells have not been characterized. As discussed above CLL cells exist in two states which will have different metabolic requirements and local resources. In the peripheral circulation CLL cells may use oxidative phosphorylation similar to their normal counterparts or on the other hand these cells may use an alternative source of glucose such as fatty acid oxidation. There is also evidence which implies metabolism is slowed as the cells enter a quiescent state and that mechanisms which provide protection from metabolic stress such as hypoxia and autophagy are exploited. Importantly, there is evidence which correlates poor prognostic indicators with the ability of these cells to withstand nutrient deprivation suggesting that CLL cells are more likely to survive in the circulation and re-enter the haemic tissues. Furthermore, there is evidence of metabolic reprogramming occurring in CLL cells correlated with bad disease suggesting that these cells are more able to change their metabolic phenotype to meet energy demands. During the proliferative stage located in the secondary tissues, CLL cells likely undergo a metabolic shift to glycolysis to support proliferative activity. In order to sustain proliferation, CLL cells may influence the metabolism of the surrounding cells in the microenvironment to provide substrates and intermediates taking advantage of mechanisms which protect from oxidative stress and promote autophagy. Taken together these findings emphasize the importance of further research to better understand the difference in CLL cell metabolism between these two states and how this may provide key insights for the development of new treatments for this disease.
This work was supported by AstraZeneca (Manchester, UK.)
JonssonVHoulstonR SCatovskyDCLL family pedigree1419472004DefoicheJDebacqCAsquithBReduction of B cell turnover in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2008British Journal of Haematology1432240247OscierDFeganCHillmenPGuidelines on the diagnosis and management of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2004British Journal of Haematology1253294317MontserratESanchezbisonoJVinolasNRozmanCLymphocyte doubling time in chronic lymphocytic leukemia - analysis of its prognostic signifcance1986British Journal of Haematology623567575DamleR NWasilTFaisFIg V gene mutation status and CD38 expression as novel prognostic indicators in chronic lymphocytic leukemia1999Blood94618401847GonzalezDMartinezPWadeRMutational status of the TP53 gene as a predictor of response and survival in patients with chronic lymphocytic leukemia: results from the LRF CLL4 trial2011Journal of Clinical Oncology291622232229CrespoMBoschFVillamorNZAP-70 expression as a surrogate for immunoglobulin-variable-region mutations in chronic lymphocytic leukemia2003New England Journal of Medicine3481817641775BrodyJ IOskiF ASingerD EImpaired pentose phosphate shunt and decreased glycolytic activity in lymphocytes of chronic lymphocytic leukemia metabolic pathway1969Blood-the Journal of Hematology344421429DameshekWChronic lymphocytic leukemia-an accumulative disease of immunolgically incompetent lymphocytes1967Blood294566584GottardiDAlfaranoADeLeo AMStacchiniABerguiLCaligaris-CappioFDefective apoptosis due to bcl-2 overexpression may explain why B-CLL cells accumulate in G0. Current topics in microbiology and immunology1995194307312ZenzTMertensDKueppersRDoehnerHStilgenbauerSFrom pathogenesis to treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2010Nature Reviews Cancer1013750PepperCHoyTBentleyD PBcl-2/Bax ratios in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia and their correlation with in vitro apoptosis and clinical resistance1997British Journal of Cancer767935938KitadaSAndersenJAkarSExpression of apoptosis-regulating proteins in chronic lymphocytic leukemia: correlations with in vitro and in vivo chemoresponses1998Blood91933793389DohnerHFischerKBentzMP53 gene deletion predicts for poor survival and non-response to therapy with purine analogs in chronic B cell leukemias1995Blood85615801589PettittA RSherringtonP DCawleyJ CThe effect of p53 dysfunction on purine analogue cytotoxicity in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia1999British Journal of Haematology106410491051MessmerB TMessmerDAllenS LIn vivo measurements document the dynamic cellular kinetics of chronic lymphocytic leukemia B cells2005Journal of Clinical Investigation1153755764Rvan GentKaterA POttoS AIn vivo dynamics of stable chronic lymphocytic leukemia inversely correlate with somatic hypermutation levels and suggest no major leukemic turnover in bone marrow2008Cancer Research68241013710144TuraSCavoMGobbiMFranchiPLonidamine in the treatment of chronic lymphocytic leukemia1984Oncology419093MacIntyreD AJiménezBLewintreE JSerum metabolome analysis by 1H-NMR reveals differences between chronic lymphocytic leukaemia molecular subgroups2010Leukemia244788797SamudioIFieglMMcQueenTClise-DwyerKAndreeffMThe Warburg effect in leukemia-stroma cocultures is mediated by mitochondrial uncoupling associated with uncoupling protein 2 activation2008Cancer Research681351985205DoughtyC ABleimanB FWagnerD JAntigen receptor-mediated changes in glucose metabolism in B lymphocytes: role of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase signaling in the glycolytic control of growth2006Blood1071144584465SpanerD ELeeEShiYPPAR-alpha is a therapeutic target for chronic lymphocytic leukemia2013Leukemia27510901099GaredewAAndreassiCMoncadaSMitochondrial dynamics, biogenesis, and function are coordinated with the cell cycle by APC/C-CDH1. Cell Metabolism2012154466479ThaiparambilJ TEggersC MMarcusA IAMPK regulates mitotic spindle orientation through phosphorylation of myosin regulatory light chain. Molecular and Cellular Biology2012321632033217WangWFanJYangXAMP-activated kinase regulates cytoplasmic HuR. Molecular and Cellular Biology2002221034253436ValcourtJ RJMSLemonsHaleyE MKojimaMDemurenO OCollerH AStaying alive: metabolic adaptations to quiescence2012Cell Cycle11916801696VadlakondaLPasupuletiMPalluRRole of PI3K-AKT-mTOR and Wnt Signaling Pathways2013in Transition of G1-S Phase of Cell Cycle in Cancer Cells. Frontiers in oncology.38585HamblinT JDavisZGardinerAOscierD GStevensonF KUnmutated Ig V-H genes are associated with a more aggressive form of chronic lymphocytic leukemia1999Blood94618481854WiestnerARosenwaldABarryT SZAP-70 expression identifies a chronic lymphocytic leukemia subtype with unmutated immunoglobulin genes, inferior clinical outcome, and distinct gene expression profile2003Blood1011249444951RosenwaldAAlizadehA AWidhopfGRelation of gene expression phenotype to immunoglobulin mutation genotype in B cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia2001Journal of Experimental Medicine1941116391647StevensonF KKrysovSDaviesA JSteeleA JPackhamGB-cell receptor signaling in chronic lymphocytic leukemia2011Blood1181643134320StarostikPManshouriTO'BrienSDeficiency of the ATM protein expression defines an aggressive subgroup of B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia1998Cancer Research582045524557SchaffnerCStilgenbauerSRappoldG ADohnerHLichterPSomatic ATM mutations indicate a pathogenic role of ATM in B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia1999Blood942748753WattelEPreudhommeCHecquetBP53 mutations are associated with resistance to chemotherapy and short survival in hematologic malignancies1994Blood84931483157RossiDBruscagginASpinaVMutations of the SF3B1 splicing factor in chronic lymphocytic leukemia: association with progression and fludarabine-refractoriness2011Blood1182669046908FabbriGRasiSRossiDAnalysis of the chronic lymphocytic leukemia coding genome: role of NOTCH1 mutational activation2011Journal of Experimental Medicine208713891401PuenteX SPinyolMQuesadaVWhole-genome sequencing identifies recurrent mutations in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2011Nature4757354101105PleyerLEgleAHartmannT NGreilRMolecular and cellular mechanisms of CLL: novel therapeutic approaches. Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology200967405418Garcia-ManteigaJ MMariSGodejohannMMetabolomics of B to plasma cell differentiation2011Journal of Proteome Research10941654176CheungE CVousdenK HThe role of p53 in glucose metabolism2010Current Opinion in Cell Biology222186191MichalekR DRathmellJ CThe metabolic life and times of a T-cell. Immunological Reviews2010236190202DamleR NGhiottoFValettoAB-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells express a surface membrane phenotype of activated, antigen-experienced B lymphocytes2002Blood991140874093MoranE CKamigutiA SCawleyJ CPettittA RCytoprotective antioxidant activity of serum albumin and autocrine catalase in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2002British Journal of Haematology1162316328WarburgOPosenerKNegeleinEOn the metabolism of carcinoma cells1924Biochemische Zeitschrift152309344ChiorazziNFerrariniMB cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia: lessons learned from studies of the B cell antigen receptor. Annual Review of Immunology200321841894KrysovSPotterK NMockridgeC ISurface IgM of CLL cells displays unusual glycans indicative of engagement of antigen in vivo2010Blood1152141984205SeifertMSellmannLBloehdornJCellular origin and pathophysiology of chronic lymphocytic leukemia2012Journal of Experimental Medicine2091221832198BlairDDufortF JChilesT CProtein kinase C beta is critical for the metabolic switch to glycolysis following B-cell antigen receptor engagement2012Biochemical Journal448165169AbramsS TLakumTLinKB-cell receptor signaling in chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells is regulated by overexpressed active protein kinase C beta II2007Blood109311931201RodriguezDRamsayA JQuesadaVFunctional analysis of sucrase-isomaltase mutations from chronic lymphocytic leukemia patients. Human Molecular Genetics2013221122732282TiliEMichailleJ-JLuoZ(2012)The down-regulation of miR-125b in chronic lymphocytic leukemias leads to metabolic adaptation of cells to a transformed stateBlood1201326312638NishiHOnoKIwanagaYmicroRNA-15b modulates cellular ATP levels and degenerates mitochondria via Arl2 in neonatal rat cardiac myocytes2010Journal of Biological Chemistry285749204930VoliniaSGalassoMCostineanSReprogramming of miRNA networks in cancer and leukemia2010European Journal of Medical Research15152152Bienertova-VaskuJSanaJSlabyOThe role of microRNAs in mitochondria in cancer2013Cancer Letters336117KimH-RRoeJ-SLeeJ-EChoE-JYounH-Dp53 regulates glucose metabolism by miR-34a2013Biochemical and Biophysical Research Communications4372225231ZhuD-XZhuWFangCmiR-181a/b significantly enhances drug sensitivity in chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells via targeting multiple anti-apoptosis genes2012Carcinogenesis33712941301ZanetteD LRivadaviaFMolfettaG AmiRNA expression profiles in chronic lymphocytic and acute lymphocytic leukemia2007Brazilian Journal of Medical and Biological Research401114351440KaramMNovakLCyriacJAliANazeerTNugentFRole of fluorine-18 fluoro-deoxyglucose positron emission tomography scan in the evaluation and follow-up of patients with low-grade lymphomas2006Cancer1071175183GardnerJ RDevlinSKnappKAerobic glycolysis predicts outcome in early chronic lymphocytic leukemia2012ASH Annual Meeting Abstracts120212482BruzziJ FMacapinlacHTsimberidouA MDetection of richter's transformation of chronic lymphocytic leukemia by PET/CT2006Journal of Nuclear Medicine47812671273AltmanB JDangC VNormal and cancer cell metabolism: lymphocytes and lymphoma2012Febs Journal2791525982609TidmarshG FTannerL IO'ConnorJEngCMordecKEffect of 2-deoxyglucose, a glycolytic Inhibitor, on the ATP levels and viability of B lymphocytes from subjects with chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL). ASH Annual Meeting Abstracts2004104114810MitusW JBergnaL JMednicoffI BDameshekWCytochemical studies of glycogen content of lymphocytes in lymphocytic proliferationsBlood138748756MonahanT MMarchandN WFritzR RAbellC WCyclic adenosine 3'-5'-monophosphate levels and activities of related enzymes in normal and leukemic lymphocytes1975Cancer Research35925402547PelletierJBellotGGounonPLacas-GervaisSPouyssegurJMazureN MGlycogen synthesis is induced in hypoxia by the hypoxia-inducible factor and promotes cancer cell survival. Frontiers in oncology2012218GhoshA KShanafeltT DCimminoAAberrant regulation of pVHL levels by microRNA promotes the HIF/VEGF axis in2009CLL B cells. Blood1132255685574RicciardiM RPetrucciM TGregorjCReduced susceptibility to apoptosis correlates with kinetic quiescence in disease progression of chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2001British Journal of Haematology1132391399ArshamA MHowellJ JSimonM CA novel hypoxia-inducible factor-independent hypoxic response regulating mammalian target of rapamycin and its targets2003Journal of Biological Chemistry278322965529660LeontievaO VNatarajanVDemidenkoZ NBurdelyaL GGudkovA VBlagosklonnyM VHypoxia suppresses conversion from proliferative arrest to cellular senescence2012Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America109331331413318VermesIHaanenCRichelD JSchaafsmaM RKalsbeekBatenburgECPMReutelingspergerApoptosis and secondary necrosis of lymphocytes in culture1997Acta Haematologica981813ConsoliUEl-TounsiISandovalADifferential induction of apoptosis by fludarabine monophosphate in leukemic B and normal T cells in chronic lymphocytic leukemia1998Blood91517421748DanilovA VDanilovaO VBrownJ RRabinowitzAKleinA KHuberB TDipeptidyl peptidase 2 apoptosis assay determines the B-cell activation stage and predicts prognosis in chronic lymphocytic leukemia. Experimental Hematology2010381211671177Marelli-BergF MFuHMauroCMolecular mechanisms of metabolic reprogramming in proliferating cells: implications for T-cell-mediated immunity2012Immunology1364363369SeglenP OMunthekaasA CMASDybedalAmino acid control of protein degradation in normal and leukemic human lymphocytes1984Experimental Cell Research1551121128YangCTongYNiWInhibition of autophagy induced by overexpression of mda-7/interleukin-24 strongly augments the antileukemia activity in vitro and in vivo. Cancer Gene Therapy2010172109119MahoneyEByrdJ CJohnsonA JAutophagy and ER stress play an essential role in the mechanism of action and drug resistance of the cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor flavopiridolAutophagy93434435AudritoVVaisittiTRossiDNicotinamide blocks proliferation and induces apoptosis of chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells through activation of the p53/miR-34a/SIRT1 tumor suppressor network2011Cancer Research711344734483KovalevaVMoraRParkY JmiRNA-130a targets ATG2B and DICER1 to inhibit autophagy and trigger killing of chronic lymphocytic leukemia cells2012Cancer Research72717631772MaccallumS FGrovesM JJamesJDysregulation of autophagy in chronic lymphocytic leukemia with the small-molecule sirtuin inhibitor tenovin-6. Scientific reports2013312751275LaaneETammK PBuentkeECell death induced by dexamethasone in lymphoid leukemia is mediated through initiation of autophagy. Cell Death and Differentiation200916710181029NesteE Van DenCazinBJanssensAAcadesine for patients with relapsed/refractory chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL): a multicenter phase I/II study. Cancer chemotherapy and pharmacology2013713581591SantidrianA FGonzalez-GironesD MIglesias-SerretD(2010)AICAR induces apoptosis independently of AMPK and p53 through up-regulation of the BH3-only proteins BIM and NOXA in chronic lymphocytic leukemia cellsBlood1161630233032GranderDKharazihaPLaaneEPokrovskajaKPanaretakisTAutophagy as the main means of cytotoxicity by glucocorticoids in hematological malignancies2009Autophagy5811981200MelarangiTZhuangJLinKGlucocorticoid resistance in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia is associated with a failure of upregulated2012Bim/Bcl-2 complexes to activate Bax and Bak. Cell Death and Disease3327AmreinLSoulieresDJohnstonJ BAloyzRp53 and autophagy contribute to dasatinib resistance in primary CLL lymphocytes2011Leukemia Research35199102BonuccelliGWhitaker-MenezesDCastello-CrosRThe reverse Warburg effect glycolysis inhibitors prevent the tumor promoting effects of caveolin-1 deficient cancer associated fibroblasts2010Cell Cycle91019601971PavlidesSTsirigosAVeraILoss of stromal caveolin-1 leads to oxidative stress, mimics hypoxia and drives inflammation in the tumor microenvironment, conferring the "reverse Warburg effect": a transcriptional informatics analysis with validation2010Cell Cycle91122012219GuidoCWhitaker-MenezesDCapparelliCMetabolic reprogramming of cancer-associated fibroblasts by TGF-beta drives tumor growth connecting TGF-beta signaling with "Warburg-like" cancer metabolism and L-lactate production2012Cell Cycle111630193035SonveauxPVegranFSchroederTTargeting lactate-fueled respiration selectively kills hypoxic tumor cells in mice2008Journal of Clinical Investigation1181239303942VegranFBoidotRMichielsCSonveauxPFeronOLactate influx through the endothelial cell monocarboxylate transporter MCT1 supports an NF-kappa B/IL-8 pathway that drives tumor angiogenesis2011Cancer Research71725502560AhearneM JWillimottSPinonLEnhancement of CD154/IL4 proliferation by the T follicular helper (Tfh) cytokine, IL21 and increased numbers of circulating cells resembling Tfh cells in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2013British Journal of Haematology1623360370GhiaPCircostaPScielzoCDifferential effects on CLL cell survival exerted by different microenvironmental elements. Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia2005294135145WillimottSWagnerS DStromal cells and CD40 ligand (CD154) alter the miRNome and induce miRNA clusters including, miR-125b/miR-99a/let-7c and miR-17-92 in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2012Leukemia26511131116ZhuHShyh-ChangNSegreA V2011The Lin28/let-7 Axis Regulates Glucose Metabolism. Cell14718194JiangSZhangL-FZhangH-WA novel miR-155/miR-143 cascade controls glycolysis by regulating hexokinase 2 in breast cancer cells2012Embo Journal31819851998DormondOContrerasA GMeijerECD60-induced signaling in human endothelial cells results in mTORC2-and akt-dependent expression of vascular endothelial growth factor in vitro and in vivo2008Journal of Immunology1811180888095ZentC SLaPlantB RJohnstonP BThe treatment of recurrent/refractory chronic lymphocytic leukemia/small lymphocytic lymphoma (CLL) with everolimus results in clinical responses and mobilization of CLL cells into the circulation2010Cancer116922012207DufortF JBleimanB FGuminaM RCutting edge: IL-4-mediated protection of primary B lymphocytes from apoptosis via stat6-dependent regulation of glycolytic metabolism2007Journal of Immunology179849534957ChuKBoleyK MMoraesRBarskyS HRobertsonF MThe paradox of E-cadherin: role in response to hypoxia in the tumor microenvironment and regulation of energy metabolism2013Oncotarget43446462LutznyGKocherTSchmidt-SupprianMProtein Kinase C-beta-dependent activation of NF-kappa B in stromal cells is indispensable for the survival of chronic lymphocytic leukemia B cells in vivo2013Cancer Cell2317792ZhangWTrachoothamDLiuJStromal control of cystine metabolism promotes cancer cell survival in chronic lymphocytic leukaemia2012Nature Cell Biology143276286FajasLRe-thinking cell cycle regulators: the cross-talk with metabolism. Frontiers in oncology2013344KominskyD JCampbellE LColganS PMetabolic shifts in immunity and inflammation2010Journal of Immunology184840624068VousdenK HRyanK Mp53 and metabolism2009Nature Reviews Cancer910691700SemenzaG LHIF-1: upstream and downstream of cancer metabolism2010Current Opinion in Genetics and Development.20(1):5156